This question usually shows up after a hailstorm, or after a roofer casually mentions upgrades while standing on a ladder. Impact resistant shingles sound sensible, almost obvious, but insurance does not always move in obvious ways. Coverage depends on timing, cause of damage, and the fine print people rarely read until something breaks.
The short answer is sometimes yes, sometimes no. The longer answer is where things get interesting, and occasionally frustrating.
What impact resistant shingles actually are
Impact resistant shingles are asphalt shingles tested to withstand hail strikes better than standard options. They are commonly rated under the UL 2218 standard, with Class 4 being the highest rating. During testing, steel balls are dropped from set heights to simulate hail impacts. If the shingle resists cracking, it passes.
Impact-resistant asphalt roofing shingles are specially-engineered products designed to withstand the impact of hail, which can damage a shingle and lead to leaks. While all shingles offer some level of impact resistance, only the most durable are marketed and sold as impact-resistant shingles. When selecting shingles for your home, it’s important to remember that no product is hail-proof. Severe hail storms can damage roofing of all types and materials, but in many cases, an impact-resistant roof can save you from – or substantially reduce – damage to your home and its contents.
https://www.certainteed.com/pros-and-cons-impact-resistant-shingles
These shingles do not make a roof invincible. They reduce damage severity and frequency. That distinction matters a lot to insurance adjusters.
Insurance does not pay for upgrades by default
Insurance policies are designed to restore, not improve. This is where many homeowners get tripped up. If your home had standard asphalt shingles before the storm, the insurer is usually obligated to pay for standard asphalt shingles after the storm. They are not required to pay extra for an upgraded impact resistant system just because it sounds better.
Every year, thousands of homeowners across the country suffer costly damage to their roofs during hailstorms and other extreme weather events. According to the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) Severe Storms database, 4,436 major hail events occurred in the U.S. in 2022, and these storms caused billions of dollars in damage. One insurer alone, State Farm, reported paying out more than $3.5 billion in claims related to hail damage in 2022, a 1 billion dollar increase from the prior year.
https://www.owenscorning.com/en-us/roofing/blog/class-4-impact-resistant-roofing-shingles
In most claims, insurance pays for like kind and quality. That phrase shows up everywhere. It basically means same type, similar performance, similar cost range.
When insurance may pay for impact resistant shingles
There are situations where impact resistant shingles do get covered, fully or partially. One common case is when the local building code requires them. Some hail prone regions have updated codes that mandate higher impact ratings for new roofs. If the code requires it, insurance usually must comply.
Another scenario happens when the roof already had impact resistant shingles before the loss. In that case, replacing them with the same rating becomes part of restoring the property. Documentation matters here. Invoices, permits, or prior inspection records help a lot.
Partial coverage and upgrade credits
Some insurers offer what feels like a compromise. They pay the cost of standard shingles, and allow the homeowner to pay the difference for impact resistant ones. This is not uncommon and is often presented during the estimate review stage.
For example, if standard shingles cost $110 per square and Class 4 shingles cost $160 per square, the policy may cover the first amount while the homeowner covers the remaining difference. It is not perfect, but it opens the door.
Premium discounts tied to impact resistant shingles
Here is where insurance quietly changes tone. Many insurers offer premium discounts for homes with Class 4 impact resistant roofs. Industry data has shown reduced claim frequency in hail heavy regions for homes using higher rated shingles. Because of that, discounts of 5 to 30 percent on the wind or hail portion of premiums are sometimes applied.
These discounts vary widely. Some last for the life of the roof. Others require re inspection every few years. It depends on the carrier and state rules.
Hail damage claims and adjuster judgment
Insurance coverage also hinges on whether the roof is actually damaged. Cosmetic damage versus functional damage becomes a big debate. Impact resistant shingles may show fewer visible marks after a hailstorm, which sometimes leads adjusters to deny claims entirely.
This can feel backwards. The better roof takes less damage, so the claim gets denied. But from the insurer’s view, no functional damage means no covered loss. Homeowners should be prepared for this possibility.
Age of the roof affects everything
Many policies now include depreciation schedules or actual cash value coverage for roofs over a certain age. If a roof is 15 or 20 years old, insurance may not pay full replacement cost, regardless of shingle type.
Impact resistant shingles installed late in a roof’s life may not change claim outcomes much. Installed early, they tend to offer better long term value.
What homeowners should do before installing
Before choosing impact resistant shingles, homeowners should call their insurance provider and ask specific questions. Ask whether Class 4 shingles qualify for discounts. Ask if documentation is required. Ask how claims are handled when damage is reduced but not eliminated.
Getting answers in writing helps. Verbal assurances fade fast after storms.
Final thoughts
Insurance paying for impact resistant shingles is not a guarantee, but it is also not a myth. It lives in the gray area between policy language, local codes, and timing. For some homeowners, the upgrade pays off through premium savings and fewer repairs. For others, it becomes an out of pocket decision with long term benefits but no immediate reimbursement.
Understanding how insurers think before the roof is replaced usually saves more stress than arguing after the hail already fell.
Be First to Comment